INVESTIGATIVE REPORT | PUBLIC FINANCE & SECURITIES DISCLOSURE
Four Years of Audit Findings. None Posted Where Bond Investors Look.
By Peter C. Frank
Founder & Editor-in-Chief
From fiscal 2021 through fiscal 2024, Bloomfield's annual filings on the national municipal bond-disclosure website included its audited financial statements. None included its auditors' findings that the Town's internal financial controls were deficient. This article lays out what the records show, what federal securities law says, and what remains unanswered.
BLOOMFIELD, CT (November 16, 2026) — From August 2022 to March 2026, the Town of Bloomfield posted its annual financial reports to EMMA, the federal website for municipal bond information. Each year, independent auditors also issued a separate report that found issues with how the Town kept and reviewed its records. These reports were sent to the State of Connecticut, but none were posted on EMMA.
The auditors' findings became more serious over time. In fiscal 2021 and 2022, they described the issue as a "significant deficiency." In 2023, they called it a "material weakness," which is the most serious level. By 2024, they found two material weaknesses and said the Town's financial statements "would not be materially accurate without the above corrections."
It is up to regulators and courts to decide if any laws were broken. However, federal securities law, a 2024 Supreme Court decision, and the SEC's enforcement history outline the key questions investigators would consider. This article reviews those questions, looking at each document in turn.
What the records show
| Fiscal year | Auditors' finding | Classification | Posted to EMMA | Internal control report on EMMA? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2021 | 2021-001 | Significant deficiency | Aug. 15, 2022 | No |
| 2022 | 2022-001 (repeat) | Significant deficiency | Oct. 31, 2023 | No |
| 2023 | 2023-001 (repeat) | Material weakness | June 28, 2024 | No |
| 2024 | 2024-001 Financial Statement Close (repeat); 2024-002 General Ledger Maintenance | Two material weaknesses | March 27, 2026 | No |
All four EMMA filings are labeled as the Town's Annual Comprehensive Financial Report, or ACFR. EMMA's five-year list of the Town's financial disclosures contains those four reports and five notices that the Town missed its annual filing deadline. Nothing else is listed: no auditors' internal control reports, no single audit reports, and no unaudited financial statements.
For fiscal 2024, the Town uploaded its full audit package, which included both material weakness findings, to the State Office of Policy and Management's reporting system on March 27, 2026. The version posted to EMMA that same day is 154 pages long and ends with the Statistical Section. EMMA shows that First Security Municipal Advisors, Inc., the parent company of the Town's municipal advisor Phoenix Advisors, submitted the filing.
It was not always this way. In its January 2021 Official Statement, the Town told investors that "in the past five years, the Town has not failed to comply in any material respect" with its disclosure promises. (2021 Official Statement, p. 9)
In plain terms
An ACFR includes a town's audited financial statements. Since Bloomfield uses state and federal grant money, its auditors also have to do a "single audit" and report on the Town's internal controls. These controls are the regular checks designed to catch mistakes before they are recorded. The auditors issue these reports separately from the ACFR.
The auditors define a material weakness as a problem serious enough that there is "a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement of the entity's financial statements will not be prevented, or detected and corrected, on a timely basis."
The auditors also explain what their internal control report is and is not. They write that its purpose is "solely to describe the scope of our testing of internal control and compliance and the results of that testing," not to give an opinion on whether the Town's controls work. In the same report, they write that it "is an integral part of an audit performed in accordance with Government Auditing Standards."
The auditors gave an unmodified opinion on the FY2024 financial statements, which means they found that the final, corrected statements are fairly presented.
What the posted report tells its readers
The FY2024 ACFR posted on EMMA starts with a letter from Town management. The letter describes a "comprehensive internal control framework" and says the report's information is "complete and reliable in all material respects." The FY2023 letter uses the same wording. These statements come from management, not the auditors.
The letter also tells readers that the internal control and compliance reports are "included in separately issued single audit reports." These separate reports are filed with the State, but they are not available on EMMA.
In the report's narrative section, Management's Discussion and Analysis, it says that "actual expenditures were $106.1 million as compared to the final budget of $105.2 million, creating a favorable variance of $869 thousand." (MD&A, p. 11) However, the report's budget schedule does not show these numbers. Instead, it lists General Fund spending of $104,347,185 against a final budget of $104,391,783, and spending plus transfers of $105,447,185 against a final budget of $105,191,783, which is an overrun of $255,402. (Schedule RSI-2, p. 85)
The same section credits the positive spending results to "fiscal conservatism and effective management." (MD&A, p. 11) But a note elsewhere in the report lists 12 departments that spent more than the Town Council approved in FY2024, totaling $1,371,376. (Note 2, p. 39)
The Town had the financial numbers, but none of them were posted.
The Town's agreements with its bondholders, called Continuing Disclosure Agreements, require annual financial information within eight months after the fiscal year ends, by February 28. The agreements also reserve the Town's right to post unaudited financial statements when audited ones are not ready.
EMMA shows the Town never used that option. However, in 2025, the Town provided the State with unaudited FY2024 results on two occasions:
- An August 4, 2025, budget report showing General Fund revenues exceeding expenses by $1,217,371.83.
- A December 8, 2025, letter from the Finance Director reporting an unaudited operating surplus of "approximately $5.6 million."
A Finance Committee presentation on March 16, 2026, listed a net operating surplus of $2,052,482. The audited statements dated March 24, 2026, report a $3.2 million increase in General Fund balance.
Where else the Town's financial picture traveled
The rating agencies
Credit rating agencies assess the risk of a town's bonds, influencing the interest taxpayers pay. Charlene Butterfield, Managing Director and Head of Local Governments for the East Region at S&P Global Ratings, confirmed in writing that S&P's analysis reflected "the abridged audit document, as well as our opinion of elevated governance risk as highlighted by reduced transparency and audit delays." She did not directly answer whether S&P learned of the two FY2024 findings through other channels.
Moody's withdrew its Aa2 rating of Bloomfield on September 19, 2025. In its required federal disclosure, Moody's stated that the information available was "insufficient or otherwise inadequate for the purposes of maintaining a credit rating." (Moody's disclosure) It is not yet known what Moody's had requested from the Town, or what it received.
On December 30, 2025, S&P lowered the Town's rating from AA+ to AA and warned there was "at least a one-in-two likelihood" of withdrawing the rating within 90 days, "depending on the town's ability to provide us with its fiscal 2024 audit." S&P also stated, "Given the delays in financial reporting, we view the town's governance risk as elevated." Moody's had withdrawn its rating three months earlier, leaving S&P as the Town's sole remaining rating agency.
That same day, according to the Finance Director, the Town delivered its "fully auditable trial balance" to auditors, about 18 months after the fiscal year ended. Three weeks earlier, in a December 8, 2025, letter to the State, he explained that his staff had spent the previous five weeks on this work. Among other steps, they had "[r]esearched accounts that had historical, unchanged balances going back as far as FY2008, and made adjustments to eliminate these legacy issues." (Emphasis added.) Some balances had remained unchanged for up to 16 years.
The auditors later reported that "several journal entries were posted to the general ledger without sufficient independent review," and that the financial statements "would not be materially accurate without the above corrections." They signed their report on March 24, 2026. S&P affirmed the AA rating and removed it from CreditWatch on March 30, 2026, the 90th day of its review period.
Public statements
On December 3, 2025, the Hartford Courant reported that local officials said the Moody's withdrawal "carries no penalty" because the Town's bonds are rated by S&P. Twenty-seven days later, S&P lowered that rating.
The Courant also reported that Finance Director Darrell Hill told the Council in November 2025: "There is sufficient information with regard to approximate levels of unassigned fund balance." He expected the FY2025 audit to be completed "before June 30 so we don't again cross over into being non-compliant." As of mid-November 2026, the State's reporting system showed no FY2025 audit.
The Town's website
On its own website, the Town posts its separately issued single audit reports alongside its annual financial reports for multiple years. As of November 2026, the Town's online archive and document center post the 154-page FY2024 Annual Audit, the FY2024 Federal Single Audit (which contains both material weakness findings), and the FY2024 State Single Audit, as well as the FY2023 Federal Single Audit, the FY2023 State Single Audit, and the FY2022 State Single Audit.
What federal law requires
Municipal bonds are not registered with the SEC the way corporate stock is. Instead, SEC Rule 15c2-12 requires the banks that underwrite municipal bonds to ensure the issuing town has promised to post annual financial information and notices of certain events on EMMA. Those promises are the Continuing Disclosure Agreements.
Separately, federal anti-fraud law applies to what a town says to investors. In a 2020 staff bulletin, the SEC's Office of Municipal Securities said the anti-fraud rules apply to a municipal issuer's statements that are reasonably expected to reach investors, including its EMMA filings. The bulletin reflects staff views and states that it has no legal force.
In a June 30, 2025, speech to the Government Finance Officers Association, Dave A. Sanchez, director of the SEC's Office of Municipal Securities, said that "adhering to your continuing disclosure undertakings does not preclude you from providing additional information, particularly where disclosure may be necessary to avoid liability under the antifraud provisions." He noted that his remarks do not necessarily reflect the views of the Commission.
In a 2013 report on Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, the Commission itself warned that public officials should be "mindful that their public statements, whether written or oral, may affect the total mix of information available to investors."
The scienter question
To prove securities fraud under Rule 10b-5, the SEC must show there was a false or misleading statement about something important to investors, made with "scienter." The U.S. Supreme Court defines scienter as "a mental state embracing intent to deceive, manipulate, or defraud" (Ernst & Ernst v. Hochfelder, 1976). In the federal appeals circuit covering Connecticut, extreme recklessness can also count (Novak v. Kasaks, 2000), but ordinary carelessness does not.
In 2024, the Supreme Court set a new limit. In Macquarie Infrastructure Corp. v. Moab Partners, it ruled that "pure omissions are not actionable under Rule 10b-5(b)." So, silence alone is not considered fraud under this rule. However, a statement that is technically true but misleading because of what it leaves out—a "half-truth"—can be considered fraud.
This framework leads to specific questions, each connected to a particular document.
- Did the Town know about the findings? The auditors' internal control reports are addressed to the Town Council. For FY2024, management responded in writing: "Management agrees with the finding," and, for the second finding, "There is no disagreement with the audit finding."
- Was it repeated? Yes. The findings showed up in four straight years and became more serious over time. None of these findings appeared in the four EMMA filings.
- Did the posted reports include statements that the missing findings could make misleading? The transmittal letters describe a "comprehensive internal control framework" and say the information is "complete and reliable in all material respects." Whether these statements are half-truths or accurate descriptions of the final audited numbers is the type of question Macquarie leaves for investigators and courts to decide.
- Did the Town sell bonds during this time? Yes. The Town issued $14 million in bonds and $17.25 million in short-term notes in January 2024, and another $17.25 million in bonds in January 2025. In a letter to the State on August 4, 2025, the Finance Director said his department had been focused on "identifying and resolving significant recordkeeping deficiencies in FY2024" and "the January 2025 refinancing."
- Did the offering documents for those sales mention the auditors' findings? No. Neither the January 2024 nor the January 2025 Official Statement uses the phrases "material weakness" or "significant deficiency." Both include excerpts of the Town's audited financial statements, but neither includes the auditors' internal control reports. When the Town sold bonds in January 2025, its auditors had issued the FY2023 material weakness finding about seven months earlier. The 2024 and 2025 Official Statements disclosed the Town's late annual filings for FY2021 and FY2022 (2024 Official Statement, p. 10) and, in 2025, FY2023 (2025 Official Statement, pp. 7–8).
- Did officials make reassuring public statements? See the December 2025 statements reported by the Hartford Courant, above.
- Did the Town have another option? Its disclosure agreements allowed it to provide unaudited statements. The Town gave unaudited figures to the State, but not to EMMA.
One fact cuts against any inference that the Town intended to conceal the findings: the Town posted the single audit reports, including the internal control findings, on its own website.
A lower bar: negligence
The SEC does not always need to prove intent. Under Section 17(a)(2) and (3) of the Securities Act of 1933, negligence can be enough (Aaron v. SEC, 1980), but only for statements made during the offer or sale of securities, like a bond sale. The SEC has used these rules against states, including New Jersey in 2010 and Illinois in 2013. Both cases settled without the states admitting or denying the findings.
The SEC has also gone to trial. In 2016, a federal jury in Miami found the City of Miami and its former budget director liable for securities fraud over three 2009 bond offerings. The SEC's case centered on interfund transfers used to mask a deficit. The city later paid a $1 million civil penalty. (SEC statement)
What the Town would likely say
- Its disclosure agreements require audited financial statements, and it posted them. The internal control reports are a separate state and federal compliance document.
- Rule 15c2-12 does not require issuers to disclose material weaknesses in internal control.
- In the same 2025 speech, Sanchez said issuers could make additional disclosures available "on the EMMA system and/or on their own websites." The Town posts its single audit reports on its website.
- The full audit package was filed with the State, is a public record, and is posted on the Town's website. The posted ACFR also tells readers that the separate reports exist.
- The auditors' opinion on the final financial statements is unmodified.
- Its Official Statements disclosed its late filings.
- Through Phoenix Advisors, it filed EMMA notices of the Moody's withdrawal and the S&P downgrade within two business days (Sept. 23, 2025, and Jan. 2, 2026).
- The auditors themselves attributed the problems to staff turnover in the Finance Department.
- The Town has not missed a bond payment, and no regulator has announced any action involving the Town.
Other exposure
- Individual officials. The Harrisburg report and the Miami verdict show the SEC can pursue public officials, not just towns. This article does not suggest that any Bloomfield official has done anything that would warrant such action.
- Municipal advisors. A September 16, 2026, statement by the staff of the SEC's Office of Municipal Securities says that, depending on the facts and circumstances, "when the municipal advisor has a role in disclosure, the municipal advisor should perform an appropriate level of inquiry into the accuracy and completeness of the disclosure." The same statement says purely clerical services are not municipal advisory activity, and that it reflects staff views with no legal force. EMMA lists Phoenix Advisors' parent company as the submitter of the Town's FY2024 filing. What role, if any, Phoenix had beyond submitting it is not known.
- A five-year shadow. Under Rule 15c2-12, each Official Statement the Town issues must describe any failure to meet its disclosure promises in the past five years. The FY2025 failure, posted on March 2, 2026, must be disclosed in the Town's Official Statements through early 2031.
- State oversight. In July 2025, the State notified the Town that it was eligible for "Tier I" oversight by the Municipal Finance Advisory Commission under C.G.S. § 7-395d.
- Borrowing costs. The Town no longer has a Moody's rating, and S&P has lowered its rating by one notch and described governance risk as "elevated." Lower ratings usually mean higher interest costs, which are paid by taxpayers.
- Bondholder remedies. The Town's Continuing Disclosure Agreements state that a failure to comply is not a default on the bonds and limit bondholders to a suit for specific performance, with no monetary damages.
What we do not know
- Who decided what went into each EMMA filing.
- Whether anyone advised the Town to include, or leave out, the internal control reports.
- What the Town gave Moody's before the withdrawal.
- Whether any regulator has looked at these filings. An SEC spokesperson said the agency "does not comment on the existence or nonexistence of a possible investigation."
Questions that remain open
- Why were the auditors' internal control reports not included in the Town's EMMA filings for fiscal years 2021 through 2024?
- Why did the Town give unaudited FY2024 results to the State but post none to EMMA?
- Was the Town Council told what each EMMA filing contained?
- What did the Town provide to Moody's and S&P, and when?
- When will the FY2025 audit be filed, and is the FY2026 audit on track for the State's December 31, 2026, deadline?
Responses
Editor's note: On Friday, November 13, 2026, at 9:00 p.m., the Dispatch sent Town Attorney Andrew Crumbie and Finance Director Donna Stewart seven written questions about the findings in this article, with a deadline of 9:00 p.m. Sunday, November 15. As of publication on Monday, the Town has still not responded. Namita Tripathi Shah, a partner at Day Pitney LLP, which served as bond counsel on the Town's 2021 bonds, told the Dispatch in a November 16 phone call that the firm had "no comment." Hardwick Law Firm did not respond to written questions sent October 30 and November 5. Phoenix Advisors did not respond to written questions sent October 30 and November 5, or to a phone message left November 16. Moody's did not respond by publication to questions sent November 16. In a November 16 email, an SEC spokesperson said, "The SEC does not comment on the existence or nonexistence of a possible investigation." This article does not allege that any person or entity committed securities fraud.
Documents cited
- FY2021–FY2024 audit reports and single audit reports (OPM EARS) and Town of Bloomfield Archive Center
- EMMA Financial Disclosures list for the Town of Bloomfield
- 2021, 2024, and 2025 Official Statements
- FOI 25-134 and FOI 26-19 (OPM correspondence)
- Moody's Sept. 19, 2025 withdrawal disclosure and Sept. 23, 2025 EMMA event notice
- S&P Dec. 30, 2025 and March 30, 2026 reports, and Jan. 2, 2026 EMMA event notice
- SEC Staff Legal Bulletin No. 21
- SEC Harrisburg Report, Release No. 34-69516
Comments
Post a Comment